Thursday, June 2, 2022

TL-DR Dept. - "Yes, But What Do You Think Of The Singing?"



The title of this screed was Lowell George's reply when asked why there was so little bottleneck guitar on Thanks I'll Eat It Here, an album troubled not only by the break-up of Little Feat, but also a catalog of health problems related to obesity, back surgery, and of course prodigious drug abuse; heroin, cocaine, alcohol ... what you got? Thanks! I'll eat it here. But there's another possible reason for the delays and difficulties - chronic lack of self-confidence.

He knew his songwriting was a cake left out in the rain. He couldn't come up with enough material for a Little Feat album, leave alone a solo project. As a direct result of his reduced creativity, the other writers stepped up to fill the gap. I'm sure everybody would have been happy if Lowell continued to be the band's principal songwriter, so for him to blame Bill Payne's jazz-rock leanings for his dissatisfaction is disingenuous at best.

So, what do you want the boy to do? Can't you see it's breaking the child in two?

There was a lack of vision for the solo album, other than it was not to be a Little Feat album. Yet he covered a Little Feat tune and gave Neon Park the job of packaging it, whose style is joined at the hip with the band. Richie Hayward and Bill Payne both play on it (along with just about anybody else who could lift their face from a bowl of blow for long enough). He didn't have the confidence to cut the cord. That we got an album at all is something of a miracle. And he put a band together and started a tour and then he fell over and, for the first time, didn't get up again.

Over the years, more people have come to love this album for what it is than hate it for what it's not. It's Lowell George, singing as beautifully as ever, and maybe with a little more soul. Singing a bunch of songs which range from the ridiculous to the sublime.

The Ridiculous

Jimmy Webb, a songwriter almost without peer in Literate Pop, right up there with Paul Simon, contributes not only his worst song, but a song nearly as wretched as Maxwell's Silver Hammer. Himmler's Ring is the one song on the album everybody either hates or makes excuses for.

A sketch of a song. Ten tossed-off lines, rinse and repeat. It must have taken Webb as many minutes to write. The tone is obvious from the arrangement, but we have no idea what the song's about. Webb explains the joke: “It was a kind of a barbed wire affair with Himmler’s Ring, which I think was widely misunderstood by most people. It was a satire of a guy who collects Nazi war memorabilia. I thought that was a singular hook for a song.”

Well, yeah but no. Webb is no satirist. He's not Steely Dan. But why did Lowell include it? My guess is he asked Webb if he had something lying around, and maybe it would lighten the tone, or he was desperate to delay the tone arm on its spiral of doom to the label, and hey, it was an exclusive Jimmy Webb composition ... it had to be good, right? Right? But I'm tired of making excuses for it ("delightfully oddball", "Lowell goofing off as only he can" etc.). It doesn't sound right and it stinks and I'm never going to listen to it again. Fooey on it.

The Sublime

Twenty Million Things To Do is very possibly his finest song. He gives a co-writing credit to his eight year-old step-son, Jed Levy, who (according to Lowell) came up with the couplet "I've got twenty million things to do, but I'm only thinking of you" while fooling around with a tape recorder. A co-write in the loosest sense of the word, and a generous gift of royalties to his son-in-law.

But this isn't an album of his own compositions, which was the main reason for the disappointed reaction on release. Nor is it a showcase for his signature slide playing, another cause of chopfallen mien across the diaspora. It's all about the singing. In the blizzard of brilliance that was Little Feat, his singing tends to get overlooked.

He is a superb vocalist. And it's showcased here in a different context, on cover versions that would never have been considered for a band release, and just what is the problem here? It's unlikely anyone coming fresh to TIEIH would understand the shit flung at it by people who call themselves fans.

China White, which now heads up the album, was a victim of Lowell's inability to complete to his own satisfaction (although it sounds just fine to everybody else). After refusing to leave the studio for coke-fuelled days and nights without sleep, trying to nail the take, he had to be locked out of the building and told to go home. And it still, amazingly, didn't make the cut. A love/hate song to his addiction, it bleeds raw soul from every stretched-out, strung-out syllable.

I said blow away, blow away This cruel reality And keep me from its storm Suspicion has crept in, and ruined my life I'm messed up, and hassled, and worn

Well its pure indignation Just another sensation And I'd like to knock on that door But the boy he keeps on callin' for more Yes and my sweet China White She ain't here tonight And love has robbed me blind So cast away, cast away From this ball full of pain For it sinks beneath the waves Yes and my sweet China White She ain't here tonight Oh and love has robbed me blind Yes ahh sweet  Morphine has robbed me blind ...

I guess morphine sounds more poetic, more romantic, than heroin. It makes for a strong opening statement - confessional yet unrepentant. Not Little Feat, but pure Lowell George.

Cheek To Cheek has been dismissed by some critics as a lightweight pastiche. I don't hear that. Not only does co-writer Van Dyke Parks have a lot of respect and love for "this-type" music, but Lowell isn't camping it up. He's singing from the heart - yo soy amoroso! I suspect those sniping at the song might find it hard to believe that any American would want to sing Mexican music, which is for tourists. It's a beautiful song.

Lonesome Whistle, producer George Massenburg recalls, was recorded by Lowell in '75, as one of the first songs to be considered for the solo album. It got lost until his widow found it in a paper bag in their garage. Exactly who's playing - apart from Lowell - is unknown, but that sure ain't Richie Hayward, is it? The Hank Williams song sits perfectly in Lowell's idiosyncratic eclecticism - two words that should be seen together more frequently.

I've shuffled the running order to accommodate the additions, which helps to hear the album afresh, leaving in the sublime Heartache, the bonus cut from the recent re-issue. What we have lasts a generous 39 minutes, with six of the eleven songs written or co-written by Lowell, a higher proportion than some Feat albums. These changes, together with the eradication of Himmler's Ring, would seem to address most of the criticism the album still attracts from time to time.

The new album art features a South Central L.A. mural, which echoes the cover of that first Little Feat album, and I added Lowell looking from a window. It's not even pretending to be a better cover than Neon Park's masterpiece, but it will allow you to differentiate between this pimped-out version and the original.




48 comments:

  1. I haven't forgotten I have to loadup the Antipodean psychedelia!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Excellent writeup, great cover art. I'm not here to defend Himmler's Ring (or to bury it in Wewelsburg). You asked why Lowell chose to include it. Aside from Lowell's lack of new songs, my guesses would be that A) he thought it was funny; B) he saw it as a challenge (who else would record it?); and/or C) he was proud of how well he sang it -- as you pointed out.

    I've often wondered whether China White was cut because it's so honest. He wrote plenty of other songs about drugs (Sailin' Shoes, Fat Man, etc.), but never this directly about the toll of addiction. Maybe when the time came to finalize the track list, he didn't want to look at the man snorting coke off the mirror.

    When I put on this album, it's to listen to 20 Million Things, Can't Stand The Rain, Cheek To Cheek, and Fred Tackett's lovely Find A River.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Lowell never sung better than on Find Me A River - the ache in his voice! And I can't think of a Little Feat album it could have been on. Like China White, there's too much direct emotion.

      Delete
  3. For those who haven't seen it, Lowell and the Factory appeared on the US sitcom "F Troop" in early 1967. LG doesn't sing but he does have a few lines (of dialogue). A few years back I saw the entire episode and The Bedbugs make two appearances, the first of which is linked below.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yXP7JSmGr_4&ab_channel=EarlGuthrie

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Okay! Wow! Did not know that even existed!

      Delete
    2. Yup, this is a treasure. Lowell was The Hollywood Kid.

      Delete


  4. I like "Thanks, I’ll Eat it Here" better than the other late 70s Little Feat albums, "Waiting for Columbus" not withstanding.

    "Yes, But What Do You Think Of The Singing?"
    The power, control and projection are sublime. Euphonious in fact.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It has more heart and soul than those albums. I'll loadup this after I've given it one more play through to make sure I'm happy with the track order.

      Hey, Babs - if you feel up to it, how's about a topic for Mass Debate?

      Delete
    2. If you could host a talk show, and could have the five following guests on your show (dead or alive) who would they be?
      1st guest: An Actor
      2nd guest: A Comedian
      3rd guest: An Author
      4th Guest: A musical act
      5th guest: Your choice

      Delete
    3. Bette Davis
      Joan Rivers
      S.J. Perelman
      R. Crumb And His Cheap Suit Serenaders
      Fred Allen

      Delete
    4. Laurence Olivier
      Richard Pryor
      William Shakespeare
      The Charlie Parker All-Stars (Charlie Parker on Alto Saxophone, Miles Davis on Trumpet, John Lewis on Piano, Curly Russell on Bass and Max Roach on Drums)
      Christopher Hitchens

      Delete
    5. Marlon Brando
      Jonathan Winters
      Carl Hiaasen
      John Stewart
      Steve Allen

      Delete
    6. Babs, I like your choice of Hitchens.

      Delete
    7. His book on Kissinger is blistering. But the war criminal remains untouched.

      Delete
    8. That's an insult to scrota, scrotae, scroti - whatever

      Delete
    9. I am frequently mistaken for Mother Teresa.

      Delete
  5. Never to be confused with - "Did They Mention the Music?: The Autobiography of Henry Mancini"...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Nor "Why don't they mention the dancing? They never mention the dancing." - Leonard Cohen

      Delete
    2. Not to mention the unmentionable...

      Delete
  6. Okay, it took a little more work than I'd anticipated, a little editing in Audacity, and a whole lot of shuffling, but the applause is deafening down at the famed Imaginary Friends Tiki Hut! Gee, is it ever swell!

    Pat the heads of the Imaginary Friends:

    ヽ༼ ຈل͜ຈ༼ ▀̿̿Ĺ̯̿̿▀̿ ̿༽Ɵ͆ل͜Ɵ͆ ༽ノ


    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks -- this sounds like it's going to be a great listen. I'm lucky enough to be a very latecomer to Little Feat so it's all still fresh to me. I'm listening to Sailin' Shoes now and it sounds like the cocaine version of the strung-out shambolic Exile. It will be interesting and sad to hear Lowell slippin' and fallin' seven years down the hard road.

      Delete
    2. Well, it's a definite upgrade and a great improvement - China White was always too good to be a remnant on Hoy Hoy and Lonesome Whistle sits well in this revamp.

      Delete
    3. Also the sequencing - note sequencing! Nobody ever mentions the sequencing! Note how each track develops variety, pacing! Note overall dynamics making for cohesive, satisfying listening experience!

      Delete
    4. Many thanks for this

      Delete
    5. Thoroughly enjoyed that - big improvement, thank you. I was particularly impressed by the sequencing…

      Delete
    6. Thank you. You liked the sequencing! Nobody mentions the sequencing.

      Delete
  7. Johnny Depp
    Jimmy Durante
    Harlan Ellison
    The Hoosier Hotshots
    Johnny Carson

    ReplyDelete
  8. Lauren Bacall
    Peter Kay
    James Lee Burke
    Cara Dillon
    Ally McCoist

    ReplyDelete
  9. Will Hay
    Marty Feldman
    P G Wodehouse
    Jimi Hendrix, breaking away from Voodo Chile to do Sunshine on Leith as a tribute to The Proclaimers
    Leonardo da Vinci

    ReplyDelete
  10. John Hurt
    Buster Keaton
    Isaac Asimov
    Bob Wills
    Les Paul

    ReplyDelete
  11. Orson Welles
    George Carlin
    Max Beerbohm
    Joni Mitchell (convincingly got up as Ghandi, though)
    Jessica Rabbit

    btw the way - I like 'Himmler's Ring'. There, I've said it. Mind, I was a wee 'un when my older brother brought the LP home - very much in my 'work out why it's brilliant' years - still some way off realising that not liking his stuff was an option too...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. sorry - not sure how to de-anonymise......

      Delete
    2. "Anonymous" comments are welcome here - unusually for a music blog - but it's good form to add a name at the end so you project some kind of ersatz identity.

      Delete
  12. Jack Nicholson
    Lenny Bruce
    Lester Bangs
    The MC5
    Bebe Buell

    It's going to be a good backstage party!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. If we want to quibble about Bangs being a writer but not author, we can bring in Hunter S Thompson as backup

      Delete
    2. Lester Bangs is legit.

      As a "heads up", sometimes Lester's hospitality rider asks for three 4 FL OZ (118 mi) bottles of Robitussin DM. Other times he wants "Doors and Fours". Bonus points if you know what "Doors and Fours", without The Google.

      Delete
    3. Tell Lester not to worry; we’re serving mescaline and opium

      Delete
    4. "Doctor prescribes, drug store supplies"
      He shouda stuck with Boy Howdy Beer.

      Delete
    5. Phensedol© was the cough elixir of choice back when catching the last bus home was an admission of defeat.
      As a wee infant, my mother gave me Collis Browne's Chlorodyne© - "a mixture of laudanum (an alcoholic solution of opium), tincture of cannabis, and chloroform" - possibly the most effective panacea ever made. Also, lethal.

      Delete
  13. Chlorodyne…that takes me back…

    ReplyDelete
  14. Oh yes…
    Gordon Jackson
    Arnold Brown
    Ashley Kahn
    Lola in Slacks
    Jack Milroy

    ReplyDelete