Saturday, April 16, 2022

The Cross-Eyed Cowpoke At Carnegie Hall

That's one of his time signatures above the barn door.

In his own words: "As far as the polyrhythms are concerned a lot of that came from riding. When you’re on a ranch like that, you’re alone a lot and you’re sent for miles and miles on horseback. You either go crazy, or you start thinking. When I was riding around those hills, the sense of space and the sounds a horse’s hooves made affected me. Someone once asked me how it worked and the easiest way to explain is just for me to beat out those rhythms. You could be bored unless you have an imagination. So I'd always be thinking musically when I had jobs to pump water or ride horseback. I'd lie there under the gasoline motor that was vibrating and I'm singing rhythms against that."

Taught some pianny by his Mom, he's fudging music class at college when he meets Totally Smokin' Hot Babe Iola Whitlock [with one lucky dude, left - Ed.]. Sez she: "At the time we were married, Dave was in the army and he said to me ‘I don’t know what the future is going to be like at all, but I promise you one thing, you will never be bored.’ And he’s kept his promise.”

Spool forward to 1963, when I first hear his Greatests Hits, one of the handful of records in my parent's baffling collection, and he's gigging at the Carnegie Hall, fercrissakes. And here we hand over to Thom Jurek at the ever-unreliable Allmusic, who nails it, once and forever: "For all those who have a big axe to grind with Brubeck,  for all those who claim the band was only successful because they were predominantly white, or played pop-jazz, or catered to the exotica craze, or any of that, you are invited to have all of your preconceptions, tepid arguments, and false impressions hopelessly torn to shreds by one of the great live jazz albums of the 1960s."

Amen to that. I hate that "whitebread" dismissal. It's inverse racism. I hear more earthy authenticity in his playing than (say) Oscar Peterson's salon soirée swing. He makes supposedly difficult time signatures as natural as clopping hooves, or the arhythmic clatter of a water pump. He wrote some swell tunes, led great musicians, changed how we listen to music, and every note was a blast. I saw him late in his life, when he had to be helped across the stage. He was still having a blast.










53 comments:

  1. What was in your parents' record collection?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Pearl Williams was the Jewish Belle Barth, a Miami-based comic known for working blue. My parents would break out her "party records" — "Bagels and Lox," "A Trip Around the World" — when company came over and only then when I was fast asleep.

      Delete
  2. A Fine Old English NoblemonApril 16, 2022 at 7:45 AM

    Very little...
    Oklahoma, Sound of Music, Victoria de los Angeles, Kathleen Ferrier, Winston Churchill's Funeral, Ella in Berlin, Edith Piaf a couple of Spike Jones 78's includjng Yes We Gave No Bananas and for some strange reason, Nellie Lucher "..hurry on down to my house baby aint nobody there but me.."

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This seems about par for the course. Record albums weren't as important for them as for us.

      Delete
    2. A Fine Old English NoblemonApril 16, 2022 at 8:01 AM

      The above comment deserves to be deleted by the dyslexic author.

      I hate this touch screen keyboard, so, as I was saying:

      Very little...
      Oklahoma, Sound of Music, Victoria de los Angeles, Kathleen Ferrier, Winston Churchill's Funeral, Ella in Berlin, Edith Piaf, a couple of Spike Jones' 78's including "Yes We Have No Bananas" and for some strange reason, Nellie Lucher "..hurry on down to my house baby ain't nobody home but me.."

      Thank you and good night

      Delete
    3. Winston Churchill's Funeral.

      Sounds like the name of the best psychedelic band ever.

      Delete
    4. My parents dismissed Spike Jones as being silly.

      That was the whole damn point!

      Great stuff - and those boys could really play.


      Delete
    5. A Fine Old English NoblemonApril 16, 2022 at 5:39 PM

      Jimmy Shand - just remembered, every New Year's Eve my mother would throw a party and the furniture would all be moved to the sides of the room, Jimmy Shand would go on the record player and a load of drunken farmers would attempt to do the eightsome reel and the gay gordons and lots of other half remembered country dances from their youth. Later immortalised by Richard Thompson in "Don't sit on my Jimmie Shands"
      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6FH7Kj_V6-c

      Delete
    6. "My parents dismissed Spike Jones as being silly.

      That was the whole damn point!

      Great stuff - and those boys could really play."

      My parents were concerned about me, when I played Ornette Coleman, which they thought was weird.

      That was also the whole damn point!

      They cornered me, and asked me: "Are smoking Marijuana, Babs?" to which I answered "No" which at the time, in '65 was true. That said, I didn't tell them about the Dextroamphetamine and Librium, that were best taken together, and were what the cool kids were doing at the time.

      Great stuff also, and those boys could really play.

      Delete
  3. My parents really liked music, and had records by Glenn Miller, Bing Crosby, Jimmy Dorsey, Perry Como and The Andrews Sisters.

    My favorite records they had were by Nat "King" Cole and Billy Eckstine.

    They were also into Frank Sinatra, Dean Martin and the whole Rat Pack scene that embodied the successes and excesses of post-war America, that they enjoyed.

    They were also pretty open-minded, and would listen to rock records my brother and I had, and some of my Hard Bop Jazz records.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That was an education - and you were lucky. My Dad didn't like music (although he claimed to be a musician - I never heard any proof of that), so my Mum got up the courage to buy the occasional album, sometimes based on what she heard playing in the record store (Ike Quebec!), and some of her choices (Ike, Brubeck, Bing n' Rosie, Roger Miller, George Shearing) stay with me today. Whe I started buying my own, I had a cheap player in my room, away from my Dad's virtuoso passive-aggressivity.

      Delete
  4. My Mother gave me her collection of twist 45's & they were good.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The Twist was great. Fast black music (not you, Lester Lanin) what's not to like? See also, later, disco.

      Delete
  5. Both parents liked the big bands, Miller, Dorsey, Ellington, etc. There were also albums by Andy Williams, Frank Sinatra, Dean Martin. My dad was a big Hank Williams fan and of later c/w. I think he also must've like pop trumpet too, Al Hirt, Bert Kaempfert's Wonderland By Night, etc. For some reason in the 70s, B.J. Thomas' Raindrops Are Falling On My Head spoke some sort of cosmic truth to my mom. I remember her dancing to it in the living room, playing it over and over.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Mostly 30s and 40s stuff. Miller , Dorsey, Ellington....the works. Lots of early, and as it turned out, rare early blues. My uncle lived two doors down and was a jukebox distributor. We had early 78s from the 20s to the 50s....those are still in my older brothers collection.

    Will @UTTAF

    ReplyDelete
  7. My parents loved music and it was always "there" in the house. On the radio and later on the record player.
    They had a nice stereo - a Decca thing with a second speaker amp doodad.
    There were lots of musicals - Oklahoma, My Fair Lady, Oliver, The King & I, etc. etc.
    Les Paul & Mary Ford.
    Chet Atkins.
    Glen Miller.
    Ray Conniff.
    Jacques Loussier.
    The Swingles.
    Later on, Joan Baez.

    ReplyDelete
  8. dour original cast broadway like south pacific. 40s and 50s broadway was really depressing. popular adult music like mitch miller...jesus, i really can't continue.... and they never even played them. i was the only one that ever put on a record!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Those show tunes ere so much part of my childhood that I can still enjoy them - although I never actively seek any out! In terms of musical composition, there are some amazing songs in there.

      Delete
    2. i love many of the tunes. i dislike the broadway original cast renditions. the songs come alive for me in individual interpretations, jazz and blues versions, ella et all.

      Delete
    3. There's something about belting out a song from a stage set surrounded by people pretending to be somewhere else that kills it stone dead.

      Delete
  9. A lot of cheapo US-import 1960s MOR LPs that my divorcee Mum copped from one of her flings (inc 'Beatles Hits In The Glenn Miller' sound), a few Ray Conniffs (Like Mr Eno I was bewitched by their hyper-unreal heavenly souffle-grandeur), A K-Tel 1972 UK chart hits compilation, A Quare Fellers LP (good for faux-Irish dancing at the odd party convened for our deracinated Liverpool Taig clan), Jimmy Tarbuck singing the Rat Pack, and a Perry Como single that my poor lonely put-upon Mum cuddled up to like it was the man she was looking for among the procession of no-marks that crossed her threshold.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Brubeck's Jazz Impressions of Japan was one of the treasures I found in my parents record collection and I have been a big fan ever since. Their collection wasn't huge but also contained Stan Getz (Focus and Getz Au Go Go, and some Frank Sinatra and I still have a great love of almost all Jazz and Vocal Standards to this day. But then again I like almost everything that's not popular top-40 pablum including the schmaltzy ez-listening and pop music that used to permeate the AM airwaves in the 60s and 70s so ...

    ReplyDelete
  11. Edmundo Ros. The Spirituals To Swing Concert. The soundtrack of My Fair Lady (stage, not the movie). Benny Goodman. My dad had one of those gigantic furniture stereo enclosures, fine wood (no cheap laminate). It was (like a television) one of the signs you'd "made it" out there in the suburbs. But he wasn't big on listening.

    The Brubecks lived in Concord; my family knew them (it was a very small town; my grandfather owned the town's gas station). My father didn't have a real memory of him, as they were four years apart in age.

    ReplyDelete
  12. My old man had virtually every genre in his collection of thousands of LPs and 78s that he'd begun collecting as a young man in the UK. Principally they were classical and jazz, but he delved into everything. Later when we lived in South Africa, he avidly collected kwela and other forms of South African jazz and pop music intended for the bantu market. My father passed on to that big listening room in the sky early in this millennium, but I continue to treasure the discs my brothers and I inherited. They contributed to my own musical eclecticism and willingness to open my ears to the unfamiliar. It's hard to pick out specific titles, but his Thelonious Monk 10" LPs on Prestige are particular faves.

    ReplyDelete
  13. My Dad liked a bit of jazz and pop, I remember the Sound of Music OST, Porgy and Bess OST, Swingles and a few classical. Mum listened to the radio more.
    One album sticks out is The Peddlers, Freewheeling (jazz/pop), Dad played it one day and I thought it sounded fantastic, even though I later realized the singer wanted to be Ray Charles.
    But getting to Brubeck, I remember a family holiday in The Lake District when I was a teenager, a cassette of Brubecks greatest hits playing in the car as we arrived. Unforgettable memories.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. A Fine Old English NoblemonApril 17, 2022 at 3:26 AM

      The Peddlers : Birthday - one of my car boot sale lps - must remember to give it a listen sometime !

      Delete
    2. The Peddlers were third on the bill to Nina Simone & Dick Gregory back in '67. Professional but cold.

      Delete
    3. Drummer Trevor Morais went on to more interesting pastures with the band Quantum Jump. He also became incredibly hairy.

      Not a bad album.

      https://workupload.com/file/eEsqfjfRAjc

      Delete
  14. When I was (Much) younger, Sunday radio was BFPO and 'Take Five' was the only jazz record I remember ever being played. My parents were 'Glen Miller and The Batchelors'
    types so Sunday was the only time I had the chance to listen to anything different. That was until 1963bwhen The Beatles turned up.

    ReplyDelete
  15. My parents had a very boring and safe selection of records. Mantovani, Lawrence Welk, a tenor named James Melton, that sort of stuff. The exception was Spike Jones.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Spike Jones -- my kids (12-year-old twins) know the significance of ".....BEEEEtle-bombbbbbb!!!!!" because I grew up hearing my mom's Spike Jones records and have carried them on to this generation; Leadbelly; "long-hair music" (my mom's term for classical music). From Pops: Hank Snow's "Songs of Tragedy" (My dad looked down on country music, being a jazzbo, so this was an odd member of the parents' collection, but in his later, old age he became a huge C&W fan); Johnny Cash at Folsom and at San Quentin (I think these started his willingness to listen to C&W, which took years to develop); trad jazz (Kid Ory, Pete Fountain) -- Pops was from Chicago and liked those rhythm combos, and dated Kay Starr in the late 40s.
    Circa 1970 Pops shocked us all by admitted he liked late-model Janis Joplin, whom I have no idea how he heard; from then on, her version of "Me and Bobby McGee" was his favorite song, and he liked her old-style blues mama belting.
    My folks, otherwise, disparaged rock. Then, in 1974, my sis had her 16th birthday party, and there was a live band. This was unheard of in the small central (California) coast town we lived in, but not uncommon in L.A., where we'd moved from recently. So my folks were forced to actually listen to rock music, and....my mom flipped for it. Her new favorites were T Rex, Alice Cooper and the Allman Brothers, all of whom were in their recent florescence at the time. I made scores of tapes and CDs for her up until the 2000s, and as a result my nieces have some familiarity with 20th century rock and folk-derived music due to hearing her music while being babysat. So the cycle continues.
    C in California

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. A Fine Old English NoblemonApril 17, 2022 at 5:40 AM

      Great quote about Spike Jones on Wikipedia from his son, Spkke junior :

      "One of the things that people don't realize about Dad's kind of music is, when you replace a C-sharp with a gunshot, it has to be a C-sharp gunshot or it sounds awful."

      Delete
  17. In the early 1960s, I remember non Jazz fans having copies of Dave's "Time Out" and Miles' "Sketches of Spain".

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. A Fine Old English NoblemonApril 17, 2022 at 6:29 AM

      In the early 2020's, there's a non jazz fan like me with Time Out and Kind of Blue,oh and some John Coltrane and some Mose Allison. Is there hope for me yet? I'm picking up stuff from the Isle all the time so I haven't given up ....

      Delete
    2. I'm not a Hip Hop fan, however, Beastie Boys' "Paul's Boutique", A Tribe Called Quest's "People's Instinctive Travels and the Paths of Rhythm", Lauryn Hill's "The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill" and Dr. Dre's "The Chronic" to name, but a few are to my ears fine records.

      “There are two kinds of music. Good music, and the other kind.”
      -- Duke Ellington

      Delete
    3. There is alwaya hope for all of us, AFOEN; I understand the Buddha said we get an infinite number of retries.

      Delete
    4. I've always been able to find something that "moves me" in every music genre.

      Delete
    5. *cough* apauling - Buddha never said reincarnation - your "infinite number of retries" was a thing. He wasn't against people believing in it if the belief encouraged them to behave better and be good. Buddha says all the opportunity we get is right now, a once-only deal, now or never. People tend to be uncomfortable with that - especially Buddhists - so the idea of reincarnation is pretty attractive.

      Delete
    6. Farq, I was thinking more of this lifetime than some speculative reincarnation. I wake up each day intending to be in that never-ending moment, only to continually fall off my mindfulness tricycle then remount again. That seems to me to be the essence of the "steep path" forms of Buddhism, to keep getting back up or simply trying be present. Gautama had to keep at it too until his liberation. BTW, your question today has provoked many wonderful responses and, in my case, warm memories of my old man, pipe gripped between his molars, standing over his trusty Garrard turntable, carefully dusting a disc.

      Delete
    7. A Fine Old English NoblemonApril 17, 2022 at 8:02 AM

      Babs - absolutely right, and that's what I've found with jazz, I've definitely found things that move me, but also stuff that doesn't. I think it tends to be the more bluesy side, if that makes sense.
      I've dabbled with it for years but it's such a big subject, and I've never had a chance to study it properly, but heyho, now might be the time.

      Delete
    8. Mindfulness is a struggle, and not in a good way. You say "trying to be present", and "retries", and I'm not flinging your words back at you as you may have chosen better, but any mental exercise that involves effort is doomed to fail. The beauty of Buddha (for want of a better word) is its surprise and freshness, and that can't be forced, just allowed to happen. We fight against it - quite consciously - every moment of the day.

      Delete
  18. Does everybody have this? If you don't, speak up! It's astonishingly good - the stiff old Carnegie Hall whoops and hollers like it's a rock concert - they can't believe what they're hearing - and Joe Morello's drum solo is INSANE!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. A Fine Old English NoblemonApril 17, 2022 at 7:33 AM

      I'd welcome the chance to hear it,sir

      Delete
    2. Here you go, Nobster! You may want to skip the dreary plod of For All We Know, but the rest is golden.

      https://workupload.com/file/2YnFJ8KnpXD

      Delete
  19. Jeez, when I submitted my comment, I meant to mention Joe Morello's work with the DBQ. I've watched innumerable clips of them on YouTube just to see what Morello would do, since he 1) Never does the same thing twice and 2) Has impeccable chops. I love his unflappable appearance, too, while he sends another homerun over the bleachers.
    C in California

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. What's totally unexpected on this album is the way his star turn isn't (as you might expect) during Take Five (possibly the best-known drum solo of all time) but the epic Castillian Drums, where rivets attention for over ten increasingly unbelievable minutes.

      Delete
  20. Thanks for the link Farq, I look forward to hearing this new to me lp.

    Also I've enjoyed reading the comments on this thread, good stuff one and all.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Have been enjoying the Brubeck this morning, whilst doing light housework, and potting up tomato and chilli seedlings.

    ReplyDelete
  22. My folks weren't music fans, we had maybe 6 records in the house (Mantovani, Bing Crosby, Mitch Miller), but my dad could understand the appeal when I started buying my old records. I remember playing Monk for him, and he said "that's interesting. It's like when you get a cramp in your foot and you roll it over a beer bottle in the grass. It's kinda painful but it feels so good."

    ReplyDelete
  23. Reading all those comments triggered some memories... My mom liked music and had a record player, but played mainly mainstream stuff - James Last & His Orchestra anyone? - as she practiced dancing from time to time. My dad was I guess 'deaf' when it came to anything musical, but he usually listened along with whatever was on the turntable. In the early 70's I asked him what he wanted for his birthday & to my big surprise he requested a record: 'The Internationale'. Me being 13 years old at that time had absolutely no idea what he wanted and asked him innocently which band/singer... He replied that I should just go a recordshop and ask for it: 'obviously they would have it as it was very well known!'I was utterly flabbergasted as I had never heard it on the radio or seen it on tv (TopPop!)... Anyway, I went to some record shops who had no idea either until I found someone who referred me to go the VARA broadcasting company. Indeed there I managed to buy a copy: https://www.discogs.com/release/12438379-Rob-van-de-Meeberg-De-Stem-Des-Volks-De-Internationale On his birthday I gave it to him and he was pleased, although I doubt if he ever played more than once. Much later when I understood a bit more about the background of this socialist anthem I was even more puzzled as he never expressed much interest in politics during his life...

    ReplyDelete