![]() |
Reid Miles' original, unused cover design |
This album has had a confusing history of releases, under different titles and covers, but the story is more complicated than even the scattered Discogs listings suggest. Reid Miles, the graphic designer whose bold style revolutionized the way jazz was presented, tells the story in his autobiography Cover Story [Alfred A. Knopf, 1968 - Ed.]:
"The original title of the album was The Train And The River, and that was the brief I worked to, credited to The Jimmy Giuffre 3, and I had to work in the names of the other two guys, Ralph Peña and Jim Hall. So I got in touch with Winston Link, the railroad photographer, and asked him if he had any suitable shots, and he sent over some contact sheets, and I chose one with a locomotive steaming over a river, great shot, beautifully lit, and used that for the layout. What I didn't know is that Giuffre, whom I never met, wanted the album title to be changed to The Jimmy Giuffre 3, to make more of his name.
Then I showed the proofs to Winston Link, and he objected to me removing the car from under the bridge [left - Ed.], which was crazy, it really affected the focus of the design. The album wasn't called The Car Under The Bridge. Retouching had to be done by hand in those days, and I used ink and a brush, but Link wasn't happy, I hadn't asked him, and he made a point of it, but by the time his objection got through to the right desk at Atlantic, they'd gone with Giuffre's title change and sourced a cheesy group shot for the cover, so I quit. It was one of my real regrets, it was a nice image."Luckily, the music is unchanged (although different editions have different track lists), and here's some screed what I prepared earlier:
Airy, zen-like minimalism. Not only are there no keyboards, but there's no drummer. Bass, guitar, reed, and that's it. Bearing in mind there was no click track back then coming over the non-existent headphones, the way these guys kept to the (often complex) beat is nothing short of telepathic. There have been other drummer-free combos (The Hot Club Of France, for one), but they've tended to compensate for the lack of percussive timekeeping with strong rhythm guitar/keyboards. Here, the musicians are continuously floating around each other, keeping that invisible beat between them. None of them is plodding away like a metronome - they're playing with the beat, dancing with it, passing it around, never nailing it down. And they're having an incredible time, reveling in each other's virtuosity. What a gorgeous sound!
This post funded by Aetheric Communications Corp, Blavatsky, CT.
Your favorite jazz album cover?
ReplyDeleteMoi: Monk's Music
What class of locomotive is that. Us (ex) trainspotters need to know!!
ReplyDeleteIt is, I can reveal, a Norfolk & Western 4-8-4 #601 steaming across Bridge 201 above the New River at Radford, Virginia with Train #17, the first section of Southern's southbound "Birmingham Special". I remember this shot from the Winston Link books I used to own back when I had shelves. Fantastic photographer.
DeleteShamefully I'm only really familiar with the fabulous JG from 1961 onwards when his music got rather more "out". Ought to correct this.
ReplyDeleteHere ya go, Fanners!
Deletehttps://workupload.com/file/DwhKyTr9wSQ
I expect Peanuts Malloy has it at hi-rez FLAC or whatever but you have to stomp on his neck before he uploads anything.
Well, this is the cover that I first admired in '68 and the music housed therein has been my favourite album ever since:
Deletehttps://www.discogs.com/release/3819856-The-Jimmy-Giuffre-Trio-With-Jim-Hall-The-Train-And-The-River.
It's still my favourite LP cover (even after you put me straight in July 2019) but it's a close run thing with this:
https://www.discogs.com/release/1604664-R-Crumb-And-His-Cheap-Suit-Serenaders-Number-Two
By the way, as a matter of fact, I once uploaded Charlie Byrd's "Blues for Night People" following a polite request, which I much prefer to the neck-stomping thing.
Cheers, Peanuts Molloy.
That Cheap Suit Serenaders album is a Perfect Ten. The cover is perhaps Crumb's masterpiece - certainly the other two albums are nothing like as sweet.
Delete"The cover is perhaps Crumb's masterpiece"
DeleteThat's a tricky one. He did some stuff that I have to hide from my woke DiL, but more importantly . . . I have a book that I will never part with - https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/r-crumb-r-crumb/1103755984
- which, every couple of pages, makes me think "that's the best one". And then I turn the page . . .
He was a much better artist before he started feeling guilty and illustrating the Bible (cf. Rick Griffin, whose artistic muse flew out the window as Jesus came in the door). A brilliant graphic designer as well as illustrator, his lettering and decoration is a delight. I like the Number Two cover the best, let's put it like that, or emphasise the "perhaps".
DeleteMonk's Underground is one of the greatest covers, regardless as to genre.
ReplyDeleteMy vote goes to Donald Byrd, A New Perspective. Is that an E type Jaguar car on the cover?
ReplyDeleteI may not know much about jazz but I know what I like in album cover design, and Blue Note Records are my favourite. They were using typography in such an inventive way, often combined with wonderful photography.
Bill Evans, Jim Hall Undercurrent uses a stunning photograph too, on United Artists Records.
Bill Evans & Jim Hall Undercurrent
ReplyDeleteCecil Taylor, Tony Oxley Birdland, Neuburg 2011
ReplyDeleteor maybe it's Charles Lloyd's Waves
both excellent sets...I was never a car guy I was a transit baby
super cool! one of my favorite albums of all time!
ReplyDeletecheers
Dexter Gordon Go & other Blue Note covers
ReplyDeleteBitches Brew, cover painting by Mati Klarwein (sez Wikipedia)
ReplyDeleteWhen I was living in Providence RI in the 70s I hung out with some RISD students (and yeah, we all started a band after Talking Heads made it big). One of these guys, J.D. King, used to rant about how low the standards were in album cover design, and when something actually appealed to him, he'd sigh, "Pretty good... for an ALBUM COVER..." By the end of the decade that whole crew moved to New York and started a band... that didn't last. Still does graphic art, including album covers, some of which feature his own music. I wouldn't be at all surprised if he reads this blog.
I'm always surprised if anyone reads this blog. Most 4/5g© dive straight into the comments, which is where the good stuff is.
DeleteI bought Bitches Brew on the strength of the cover - the music was, and still is - a disappointment. I had beautiful art books about Mati Klarwein back when I had shelves, too. One of the very few "painterly" artists to get close to the LSD experience.
once upon a time we lived in a place in a house where I had my own basement space where my wife and kids did not go unless I was needed for something they couldn't handle or to wake me from my drunken slumber.I had my books vinyl booze "the important stuff" and art work.
ReplyDeleteMati Klarwein’s Annunciation/Abraxas was at it's core....then the shit happened and my drunkenness caught up with me I almost lost everything/everyone.
in short we had to move we wound up in the mts. of pa. away from my nyc stomping grounds.seventeen years later no basement no place to hang Klarwein's work it sits in a corner and the vinyl been sold to help kids with college costs.the books remained though no one here reads
now i tend to the everyday sober nasty at times but what isn't.the Bitches Brew reference set me off. my apologies to all
I've always been a fan of Dezső Csanády cover for the Roland Kirk 1963 Mercury Records album "The Roland Kirk Quartet Meets the Benny Golson Orchestra".
ReplyDelete"Cool Struttin' " - Sonny Clark - August 1958.
ReplyDeleteThe album cover, designed by Reid Miles, uses an original photograph by Francis Wolff of Alfred Lion's wife, Ruth. Lion was a German-born American record executive who co-founded the jazz record label Blue Note in 1939. Reid Miles also shot the photo for "The Basement Tapes" cover.
However, it does not come close to touching the "Monk's Music" cover. Finally, "Cool Struttin' " reminds me of Rholonne Déodoranté for some reason.
Bill Evans - Moon Beams
ReplyDeleteMiles Davis - Birth Of The Cool Beans
DeleteEdward Vesala 'Lumi' (ECM 1987)
ReplyDeleteOh got this on LP, and I love it. But yes the cover art is both boring and misleading. This however would have made it the perfect package. The B&W photograph of the train in itself, the green and yellow fonts - it's pure class. As for favorite jazz album cover, I don't know, there's so many great ones... Maybe Bill Evans / Jim Hall - Undercurrent (it's very nice album too, but far from an actual favorite of mine)
ReplyDeleteThanks, Moahaha. In the interests of transparency (an in case you didn't suspect it) the new cover is my own work, as is the fake extract from a fake book. Why do I do this? It's more interesting than jigsaws, or endless games of solitaire, I guess ...
DeleteWell, it was more than convincing enough for me - and you did excellent job with the cover design:). I'm always extra pleased when people think the mixtapes I compile (which is also more interesting than jigsaws etc...) and share, are actual existing physical objects.
DeleteThanks for bringing this to the attention of my wandering synapses again. Did you do the Barefoot Lad and Cattle Under The Bridge cover variation, too? Ha, cropped a car out of that picture, too! I quite enjoy this kind of thing. Chamber jazz isn't a disparaging term, is it? That Monk album cover pmac mentioned is great.
DeleteThis is maybe my fourth attempt at honoring Reid Miles. I don't think I'll get closer than this. It's nice that Winston Link's epic shot is from the same year.
Delete(I remember steam trains, and that memory is a precious jewel. Coaches without corridors, wood-paneled like a gentleman's club, with framed photographs above the seat backs, and windows you let down with a leather strap. And the clickety-clack down the track, and the whistle ... if heaven is conjured from your best and happiest memories, then I'll be waiting on the platform as it puffs around the curve ...)
@Moahaha - well, you fooled me! I took for granted they were actual objects!
DeleteSonny Rollins - Way Out West. The first album cover to show a black man with a gun.
ReplyDeleteHah! Good point!
Delete